Fatfatboy wrote
Not girl related,,,,
Allred,, I’ve recently came across a really nice A50 for sale and was wondering how the performance of the A50 stacked up against a A65.
Do you have any experience here?
My recollections of such things are from a bygone age, but here's what I remember............
Both the A50 and A65 in standard form are pretty low compression motors (8:1 I think) and are really nice, tractable motors and nice to ride. The standard 500 Star has around 28-32 rwhp and the standard 650 round 38rwhp, so neither are high speed machines, 90mph is probably the max for either, one probably getting there a little quicker.
Where the difference comes in is that the A65 has several variants (Thunderbolts/Lightnings/Spitfires, etc) that had increasingly larger power outputs, from 45rwhp to 52rwhp to 55rwhp, with compression ratios of 10.5:1 and high lift cams to achieve the higher top speeds expected from the buying public of the time (110mph/120mph/125mph). This not only strained the motor to limits its original design didn't foresee, it also made the machines much less tractable, increased vibration and made them less enjoyable as a daily rider, but fine for the youthful cafe racers.
The 500cc A50 didn't have the same buyer as its 650cc elder brother and so in standard "Star" form it remained a relatively docile but nice machine. It did have an increase in compression ratio and carburetor size a couple of years into production, but they were minor, just 9:1 compression and a 1" Amal which increased power output to around 32rwhp.
The only other 500 model was the Cyclone, which had twin carbs and a higher compression ratio. I never rode one of those but I can assume that while it may have had slightly more power it would not be as nice a bike to ride.
Bottom line.........from memory the 500cc A50 was a fine bike, nice temperament, fast enough for normal use
(especially with its single-leading-shoe drum front brake!). Because it doesn't have the sporty reputation of its older brother the value of the 500s are much less than the 650, and also harder to sell, so bear that in mind if you are tempted to buy, you should be able to get it for a bargain price, but conversely it may not be that easy to sell when the time comes.
.